Silvercreek Logo
receiving a hoa censure letter

Understanding HOA Board Censures: Key Things to Know

Homeowners’ associations (HOAs) are essential for maintaining order, harmony, and property values within residential communities. An important but sometimes controversial aspect of HOA governance is the concept of board censure. This blog explores the possibilities of censure within an HOA, the nature and effects of censure, and essential information that all stakeholders should know.

What is HOA Board Censure?

Censure is a formal statement of disapproval issued by the HOA board against one of its members. It is typically used to address actions or behaviors that the board deems inappropriate, unethical, or detrimental to the community. Unlike removal from office, censure does not strip a board member of their position but serves as a public reprimand aimed at correcting behavior and maintaining board integrity. (See also: “Censuring Directors“)

Possibilities Leading to Censure

Censure can be triggered by various actions or behaviors, including:

  • Violation of HOA Rules: Engaging in activities that violate the community’s governing documents, such as bylaws, CC&Rs (Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions), or state laws.
  • Conflict of Interest: Failing to disclose personal interests that conflict with the responsibilities of a board member, leading to decisions that benefit an individual over the community.
  • Unethical Conduct: Participating in actions deemed unethical, such as favoritism, discrimination, or harassment of other board members or homeowners.
  • Failure to Perform Duties: Neglecting responsibilities, failing to attend meetings regularly, or not participating in decision-making processes.
  • Disruptive Behavior: Engaging in behavior that disrupts board meetings, undermines board decisions, or sows discord within the community.
The Censure Process

The process of issuing a censure typically involves the following steps:

  1. Investigation: A formal investigation into the alleged misconduct is conducted. This may involve gathering evidence, interviewing witnesses, and reviewing relevant documents.
  2. Board Discussion: The board discusses the findings of the investigation in a closed session to protect confidentiality and ensure a fair review.
  3. Formal Vote: A formal vote is taken by the board members. Most governing documents require a majority or supermajority vote to pass a censure resolution.
  4. Issuance of Censure: If the vote passes, a formal censure statement is issued, detailing the reasons for the censure and any expectations for future conduct.

Public Reprimand

Formal Statement of Disapproval:

The censure is usually documented in the meeting minutes and involves a formal statement that outlines the reasons for the disapproval. This statement is often made public to the HOA community, which serves to inform all members of the board’s stance on the censured behavior.

Impact on the Censured Member

Reputation Damage:

The censured member may suffer damage to their reputation within the community. This can affect their standing and credibility, making it challenging to regain the trust and respect of fellow board members and homeowners.

Reduced Influence:

A censured board member may find their influence within the board diminished. They might be excluded from certain discussions, committees, or decision-making processes, limiting their ability to contribute effectively to board activities.

Emotional and Social Consequences:

The experience of being censured can be emotionally challenging, leading to feelings of isolation, embarrassment, or frustration. The social dynamics within the board may also be strained, potentially leading to further conflict or division.

Impact on the Board and Community

Board Cohesion:

Censuring a board member can affect the overall cohesion and morale of the board. It can create tension and distrust among board members, making it harder to work collaboratively on community issues.

Community Perception:

Homeowners may view the censure as a sign of internal conflict within the board, which can diminish their confidence in the board’s ability to govern effectively. However, if handled transparently and fairly, it can also reinforce the board’s commitment to maintaining ethical standards.

Precedent Setting:

Censure sets a precedent for handling similar issues in the future. It signals to all board members and homeowners that certain behaviors will not be tolerated and that the board is willing to take action to uphold community standards.

What Board Members and Homeowners Should Know

To ensure fairness and maintain trust, it’s essential for both board members and homeowners to understand and navigate the censure process effectively:

  1. Know the Governing Documents: Familiarize yourself with the HOA’s bylaws, CC&Rs, and any relevant state laws that outline the censure process and grounds for censure.
  2. Promote Ethical Conduct: Board members should adhere to high standards of ethical conduct and transparency to avoid actions that could lead to censure.
  3. Ensure Fairness: The censure process should be fair, transparent, and consistent, with clear guidelines on what constitutes censurable behavior and the steps involved in issuing a censure.
  4. Communicate Effectively: Maintain open lines of communication within the board and with homeowners to address concerns before they escalate to the point of requiring censure.
  5. Seek Legal Counsel: In complex cases, seeking legal counsel can ensure that the censure process complies with governing documents and state laws, protecting the rights of all parties involved.
  6. Focus on Resolution: The ultimate goal of censure should be to correct behavior and restore harmony within the board and the community. Encourage a path towards resolution and improvement rather than punitive measures.

Moving Forward After Censure

Behavioral Correction:

The primary goal of censure is to correct the censured member’s behavior. The board may outline specific expectations or conditions for the member to meet in order to restore their standing.

Restoration of Trust:

Efforts should be made to restore trust and improve relationships within the board and the community. This can involve open communication, conflict resolution processes, and ongoing dialogue to address any underlying issues.

Continued Participation:

The censured member continues to serve on the board and is expected to fulfill their duties, albeit with the awareness of the board’s disapproval. They have the opportunity to demonstrate improved behavior and regain the trust of their peers over time.

Legal and Governance Considerations:

Boards should ensure that the censure process is conducted in accordance with the HOA’s governing documents and relevant state laws to avoid potential legal challenges. Legal counsel may be sought to ensure compliance and fairness.

Conclusion

Censure is a significant tool within HOA governance designed to address misconduct and maintain board integrity. While it serves as a formal reprimand, it is crucial for the process to be conducted fairly and transparently to uphold the trust and confidence of the community. By understanding the possibilities leading to censure, the process itself, and the effects it can have, board members and homeowners can better navigate these challenging situations and work towards a cohesive, well-governed community.

Please contact Silvercreek for more information about censures and what you can do to avoid them. Contact Us.

Sacramento
6060 Sunrise Vista DR. #3400
Sacramento, CA 95610
(916) 877-7793


Walnut Creek
2950 Buskirk Ave. #300
Walnut Creek, CA 94597
(925) 690-5332


San Jose
1999 S Bascom Ave. #700
Campbell, CA 95008
(800) 922-1106


 

SACRAMENTO

Sacramento Office
6060 Sunrise Vista Dr. #3400
Citrus Heights, CA 95610

Sacramento Map

WALNUT CREEK

Walnut Creek Office
2950 Buskirk Ave. #300
Walnut Creek, CA 94597

Walnut Creek Map

SAN JOSE

San Jose Office
1999 South Bascom Ave #700
Campbell, CA 95008

San Jose Map

© 2024 Silvercreek Association Management | All Rights Reserved.

Website by Breakpoint

silvercreek light logo
SACRAMENTO

Sacramento Office
6060 Sunrise Vista Dr. #3400
Citrus Heights, CA 95610

Sacramento Map

WALNUT CREEK

Walnut Creek Office
2950 Buskirk Ave. #300
Walnut Creek, CA 94597

Walnut Creek Map

SAN JOSE

San Jose Office
1999 South Bascom Ave #700
Campbell, CA 95008

San Jose Map

© 2024 Silvercreek Association Management | All Rights Reserved.

Website by Breakpoint